Is it better to fly or train?

Flying is much faster and often cheaper.

Rideshare or private car from Slinger.

Do I need a car in NYC?

No, a car is a liability in the city.

What is the best airport?

LaGuardia is closest to Manhattan.

Yes, especially through the Finger Lakes region.

Slinger

New York

Train Flight

Slinger to New York

Updated: 31 May 2026

The trip from Slinger to New York City is best accomplished by flying from Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport (MKE) to LaGuardia (LGA) or JFK. The flight duration is approximately 2.5 hours. Alternatively, you can take an Amtrak train from the Milwaukee Intermodal Station, though this requires a transfer in Chicago. Driving is a long 14-hour journey via I-90 E and I-80 E. New York City is a major transit hub with extensive subway access.

Total Distance: Driving distance 1,450 km, straight-line air distance 1,250 km.

Fastest Way

Direct flight from MKE to LGA.

Cheapest Way

Flight booked in advance, often cheaper than train.

Compare Slinger to New York Routes

	Train Connecting	Flight Direct
Duration	22 hours	2 hours 30 mins
Avg Price	$180-$350	$200-$450
Operator	Amtrak	Delta Air Lines
Route	Hiawatha to Chicago, then Lake Shore Limited to NYC	MKE to LGA
Tip	Book a roomette for comfort on the overnight leg.	Direct flights are available and recommended.

Travel Tips

Subway
Use the MTA subway system; it is the fastest way to get around.
Walking
Wear comfortable shoes as you will walk significantly more than expected.
Dining
Try local pizza slices and bagels for an authentic experience.
Tickets
Book Broadway tickets online in advance to save money.
Navigation
Use apps like Google Maps for real-time subway updates.