Is it better to fly or drive?

Flying is significantly faster and less stressful than driving.

Expect to pay over $50 in tolls if driving through PA and NJ.

Do I need a car in NYC?

No, a car is a liability in NYC due to traffic and parking costs.

What is the best airport?

LaGuardia is closest to Manhattan, but JFK has more international options.

How long is the train?

Amtrak takes over 15 hours with transfers; it is not recommended.

Anderson

New York

Flight Driving

Anderson to New York

Updated: 28 May 2026

The distance from Anderson to New York City is approximately 1,100 kilometers. Flying from Indianapolis (IND) to LaGuardia (LGA) or JFK is the most efficient method, taking about 2 hours in the air. Driving takes roughly 12 to 14 hours via I-70 E and I-80 E, passing through Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. Driving involves significant tolls on the Pennsylvania Turnpike and New Jersey Turnpike. Flying is highly recommended to avoid the stress of navigating NYC traffic.

Total Distance: 1,100 km driving distance; 950 km straight-line air distance.

Fastest Way

Flying from Indianapolis is the fastest, taking 2 hours.

Cheapest Way

Driving is cheaper for groups, but flying is more time-efficient.

Compare Anderson to New York Routes

	Flight Direct	Driving Direct
Duration	2 hours	13 hours
Avg Price	$250-$500	$150-$200 in fuel + tolls
Operator	United Airlines	Personal Vehicle
Route	IND to LGA/JFK.	I-70 E to I-76 E (PA Turnpike) to I-80 E.
Tip	Book flights to LaGuardia for easier access to Manhattan.	Prepare for high toll costs on the Pennsylvania and New Jersey Turnpikes.

Travel Tips

Transport
Use the NYC Subway system; it is the fastest way to get around the city.
Airport
Take the AirTrain from JFK to the subway for a cost-effective transfer.
Driving
Avoid driving in Manhattan; parking is extremely expensive and limited.
Walking
Bring comfortable walking shoes; you will likely walk several miles daily.
Booking
Book Broadway tickets in advance to secure better seats and prices.